AnimeHub
Why is Attack on Titan's Manga Ending So Controversial?
Anime Features

Why is Attack on Titan's Manga Ending So Controversial?

  • 03-Mar-2024, 16:31
  • 0 Comments
  • 15 views

     SUMMARY

  •  Eren's controversial decisions in Attack on Titan have divided fans and left the ending unsatisfying for some.
  •  Series creator Hajime Isayama expressed regrets about the ending, wanting to give Eren a heroic conclusion despite his villainous actions.
  •  Despite the polarizing finale, Attack on Titan remains a masterpiece recognized for its phenomenal storytelling and commercial success.   

The final chapters of "Attack on Titan" brought the long-standing conflict between the Eldians and Marleyans to a head, with Paradis Island becoming the focal point of the war. As Eren Yeager, the protagonist, initiated the Rumbling, unleashing the power of the Founding Titan to summon countless Titans to destroy humanity beyond the island's walls, the story reached a climactic moment.

However, many fans felt that the resolution of this conflict, particularly Eren's actions and ultimate fate, left much to be desired. Eren's transformation into a seemingly irredeemable antagonist conflicted with his previous characterization as a complex and morally ambiguous hero. Furthermore, the revelation that Eren had manipulated his friends and allies throughout the series, including orchestrating the deaths of countless innocents, was a bitter pill for many fans to swallow.

The divisive nature of the ending was further exacerbated by the ambiguity surrounding Eren's motivations and the ultimate message of the story. Some fans interpreted Eren's actions as a necessary sacrifice to ensure the survival of Paradis Island and its people, while others viewed his behavior as morally reprehensible and inconsistent with the themes of freedom and justice that had been central to the series.

Ultimately, the unsatisfying conclusion of the war for Paradis left many fans feeling disappointed and disillusioned with the series as a whole. Hajime Isayama's admission that he was not entirely satisfied with the ending only added fuel to the fire, leading to widespread debate and discussion among fans about the meaning and legacy of "Attack on Titan."

 

Eren Yeager's redemption arc in the final chapters of "Attack on Titan" was indeed a point of contention among fans. Throughout the series, Eren's character had been portrayed as driven by a desire for freedom and justice, often at great personal cost. However, his transformation into the orchestrator of mass genocide during the Rumbling seemed to contradict these ideals and raised questions about his motivations and morality.

The decision to portray Eren as a sympathetic figure in the final chapters, particularly in his interactions with Mikasa, drew criticism from fans who felt that it undermined the severity of his actions and the impact they had on the story's world. Some argued that Eren's redemption felt rushed and unearned, given the magnitude of his crimes and the lack of consequences he faced for them.

Furthermore, the ambiguity surrounding Eren's ultimate goals and motivations left many fans feeling unsatisfied with his character arc. While some interpreted Eren's actions as a misguided attempt to protect his loved ones and ensure the survival of Paradis Island, others saw him as a morally compromised figure who had lost sight of his original ideals.

Overall, Eren Yeager's controversial redemption arc in the final chapters of "Attack on Titan" contributed to the divisive reception of the series' ending and sparked debate among fans about the nature of his character and the thematic implications of his actions.

The revelation of Eren's plan to become the villain as a means to ultimately save his friends and end the Titans added another layer of complexity to his character and the series' overarching narrative. This coda, presented in the final chapters of "Attack on Titan," further divided fans and sparked intense debate about the moral implications of Eren's actions and the validity of his redemption.

For some fans, Eren's self-sacrificial plan added depth to his character and provided a compelling explanation for his seemingly inexplicable shift to villainy. They interpreted his actions as a desperate attempt to protect his loved ones and ensure the survival of Paradis Island, even if it meant shouldering the burden of becoming a villain and committing unspeakable acts.

However, others found Eren's plan to be morally dubious and questioned the ethicality of his decision to sacrifice countless lives for the greater good. They argued that Eren's actions crossed a moral line and that his supposed redemption at the end of the series did not absolve him of the atrocities he committed during the Rumbling.

Ultimately, the coda of "Attack on Titan" added further complexity to the series' themes of morality, sacrifice, and the nature of heroism. It left fans grappling with difficult questions about the responsibilities of individuals in the face of overwhelming adversity and the blurred lines between heroism and villainy.


 

Hajime Isayama's admission of regret regarding the ending of "Attack on Titan" further underscores the complexity and contentious nature of the series' conclusion. The revelation that Eren's efforts ultimately failed, leading to further violence and destruction, adds another layer of ambiguity to the narrative and challenges the notion of redemption that was hinted at earlier in the series.

The compressed pacing and abrupt shift in tone in the final chapters may have contributed to the sense of dissatisfaction among fans, as the resolution of the conflict and the aftermath felt rushed and insufficiently explored. The abrupt revelation of Paradis' eventual downfall may have left readers feeling unsettled and questioning the ultimate meaning and consequences of Eren's actions.

Isayama's expression of regret suggests that he may have had different intentions or envisioned a different outcome for the series' conclusion. The complexity and ambiguity of "Attack on Titan's" ending continue to fuel discussions and interpretations among fans, highlighting the enduring impact and legacy of the series as a whole.

Despite the controversy surrounding its ending, "Attack on Titan" remains a masterpiece manga that has left a lasting impact on the anime and manga community. Hajime Isayama's creation captivated audiences with its intricate world-building, complex characters, and gripping storytelling throughout its 11-year publication run.

The series explored themes of power, freedom, and the consequences of war in a thought-provoking and often brutal manner. It challenged readers to question the nature of morality and the lengths individuals will go to in order to achieve their goals.

While the ending may have left some fans disappointed, the journey of "Attack on Titan" as a whole continues to be celebrated for its bold storytelling and emotional depth. It has sparked countless discussions, theories, and interpretations, solidifying its place as one of the most influential and memorable manga of its time.

As fans reflect on the series and its conclusion, "Attack on Titan" remains a testament to the power of storytelling and the impact that manga and anime can have on audiences around the world.

For those interested in experiencing "Attack on Titan," there are several ways to dive into the series:

1. **Read the Manga**: The original source material, Hajime Isayama's manga, is the best place to start. You can read the entire series from beginning to end to get the full story and experience all the twists and turns firsthand.

2. **Watch the Anime**: The "Attack on Titan" anime adaptation is a faithful retelling of the manga and offers stunning visuals, intense action scenes, and a captivating soundtrack. You can watch the anime series, which consists of multiple seasons, to immerse yourself in the world of Titans and humanity's struggle for survival.

3. **Explore Spin-offs and Side Stories**: In addition to the main series, there are also spin-off manga and light novels that expand upon the "Attack on Titan" universe. These include titles like "Attack on Titan: Before the Fall," "Attack on Titan: No Regrets," and "Attack on Titan: Lost Girls," among others.

4. **Play Video Games**: "Attack on Titan" has been adapted into several video games, including action-adventure titles and tactical RPGs. Playing these games can provide a new perspective on the series and allow fans to engage with the story in a different way.

5. **Watch the Live-Action Adaptations**: While not as well-received as the manga and anime, there are live-action film adaptations of "Attack on Titan" that offer a different take on the story. These films may appeal to fans looking for a new interpretation of the series.

Overall, whether you choose to read the manga, watch the anime, or explore other media adaptations, "Attack on Titan" offers a thrilling and unforgettable journey that has left a lasting impact on fans around the world.

  

"Attack on Titan" has certainly left an indelible mark on both the manga and anime industries, captivating audiences with its intense storytelling, intricate world-building, and memorable characters. Whether you choose to experience the series through the original manga, the anime adaptation, or both, there's no denying its impact on the medium as a whole.


Comments (0)
Add a comment

Site Categories

Tag cloud
Site cu Footermenu